The Difference Between Homeowners Insurance and Landlord Insurance
See How We're Different
or call us: 405-832-1740
By: Taylor Richardson
Founder & CEO of
5M Insurance
If a storm rips through a primary home, a standard homeowners policy is usually what saves the budget. If a tenant starts a kitchen fire in a rental property, though, that same policy may leave the owner exposed in surprising ways.
That difference catches a lot of property owners off guard. Many assume homeowners insurance and landlord insurance are just two labels for the same type of protection. In reality, they are built for different risks, different living situations, and different legal responsibilities. According to a national insurance factbook, about ninety three percent of homeowners carry basic homeowners insurance because mortgage lenders usually require it, which shows how central this coverage has become to financial planning for a home according to industry data.
Why The Difference Between Homeowners And Landlord Insurance Matters
Deciding whether a property is a home or an investment is more than an emotional question. Insurance companies look at occupancy, who lives there, how long they stay, and whether rent changes hands. Once tenants enter the picture, the risk profile changes completely, and so do the coverage expectations.
The rental market shows how large this group of property owners has become. As of the final quarter of twenty twenty four, about forty five and a half million households in the United States were renter occupied, even though the rental vacancy rate sat at six point nine percent, which highlights how many properties are now run as rentals rather than primary homes based on national housing statistics.
For owners, misclassifying a policy can be expensive. A claim that would have been covered under a dedicated landlord policy might be denied if the insurer learns that the property has been rented out under a standard homeowners contract. That can affect not only repairs but also legal costs and lost income if the place is unlivable for a while. Understanding where homeowners coverage stops and landlord coverage begins is the first step to avoiding that gap.
What Homeowners Insurance Typically Covers
Homeowners insurance is built for an owner occupied residence. The assumption is that the person who owns the property also lives there, keeps an eye on maintenance, and stores most of their belongings inside. Policies reflect that mix of building, personal property, and personal liability risk.
Dwelling And Attached Structures
The core of a homeowners policy is dwelling coverage. This pays to repair or rebuild the house itself after covered events such as fire, certain types of storm damage, or vandalism. Attached structures like a garage or a deck usually fall under this same bucket. The limit should be high enough to rebuild the home at current construction costs, not just to pay off the mortgage.
Personal Property And Loss Of Use
Homeowners coverage also protects the personal belongings inside the home. Furniture, clothing, electronics, appliances, and many other items are covered up to the policy limits, subject to deductibles and any category caps. If a covered loss makes the home uninhabitable, the policy typically pays for additional living expenses, such as temporary housing and increased food costs, under a coverage known as loss of use.
Personal Liability For Owners
Liability coverage under a homeowners policy is personal. It follows the owner and household members when they accidentally cause bodily injury or property damage to others, both on and off the property, up to the chosen limit. An industry factbook notes that homeowners insurance made up about fourteen and a half percent of all property and casualty insurance premiums and twenty seven point three percent of personal lines premiums in twenty nineteen, which shows how central homeowners liability and property coverage are in the insurance market according to an insurance factbook report.
What Landlord Insurance Typically Covers
Landlord insurance, sometimes called dwelling fire or rental property insurance, shifts the focus. Instead of protecting an owner who lives in the home full time, it protects an owner who rents the space out to others. The structure is still important, but the day to day contents are mostly the tenant’s responsibility, and the liability risk looks different as well.
Dwelling Coverage For Rental Properties
For rental properties, the building often represents the largest financial asset. Landlord policies usually center on robust dwelling coverage tailored to rental risks, such as damage caused by tenants, certain types of vandalism, and extended periods where the owner is not on site. Some policies also cover items the owner provides, like major appliances or furnishings in a furnished unit.
Licensed insurance agent Kristen Gryglik recommends that landlords carry home insurance with at least two hundred thousand dollars in dwelling coverage, along with strong liability protection and loss of rental income coverage, to stay fully protected against serious claims according to her expert guidance.
Loss Of Rental Income
One of the biggest differences between homeowners and landlord policies is the way they treat income. For owner occupied homes, the policy pays for extra living costs. For rentals, the financial hit is lost rent when tenants cannot safely live in the unit after a covered claim. Many landlord policies include coverage for this lost rental income, at least for a defined period, so mortgage payments and other expenses can still be made while repairs are underway.
Landlord Liability
Liability coverage for landlords is focused on businesslike risk on the premises. If a tenant or guest is injured because of a condition that the owner should have reasonably addressed, the landlord liability coverage can respond to pay medical bills, legal defense, and settlements or judgments, up to policy limits. This is separate from a tenant’s own liability coverage, which is usually carried under a renters policy.
Key Differences Between Homeowners And Landlord Insurance
At a glance, both types of policies mention perils like fire or wind, deductibles, and liability protection. Under the surface, though, they respond very differently once a tenant is involved. Coverage triggers, property categories, and even pricing diverge in ways that matter when something actually goes wrong.
One major distinction is cost. Landlord insurance policies tend to be more expensive because insurers see higher and more complex risks when a property is tenant occupied. Industry comparisons suggest that landlord policies cost roughly twenty five percent more than similar homeowners policies for the same property, which reflects the extra exposure from rental activity and extended periods when the owner is not present based on independent insurance analysis.
Side By Side Coverage Comparison
It helps to see the coverage differences laid out next to each other. The table below highlights how a standard homeowners policy stacks up against a typical landlord policy for key features.
| Coverage Feature | Homeowners Insurance | Landlord Insurance | Why It Matters |
|---|---|---|---|
| Dwelling (building) coverage | Covers owner occupied home and attached structures | Covers rental structure, often with options tailored to tenant related risks | Both protect the building, but landlord policies are designed for non owner occupancy. |
| Personal property | Broad protection for the owner’s belongings inside the home | Usually only limited coverage for items the owner provides, such as appliances | Tenants generally need their own renters policy to protect their belongings. |
| Loss of use or loss of rent | Pays for additional living expenses if the owner must move out after a covered loss | Pays for lost rental income if the unit is uninhabitable due to a covered loss | Homeowners are reimbursed for living elsewhere, landlords are reimbursed for lost rent. |
| Liability coverage | Personal liability for the owner and household members, on and off premises | Premises liability tied to the rental property and landlord responsibilities | Landlord liability centers on property conditions and tenant or guest injuries. |
| Occupancy expectations | Assumes the owner lives in the home as a primary residence | Assumes tenants occupy the property, sometimes with minimum lease terms | Misclassification can lead to denied claims if a home is rented out under a homeowners policy. |
| Optional add ons | May include endorsements for high value items, water backup, or home based business risks | May include coverage for tenant damage, legal expenses related to evictions, or extended loss of rent | Endorsements let owners tailor coverage to how they actually use the property. |
How To Choose The Right Policy For Your Property
The right coverage starts with a clear picture of how the property is used. Insurers distinguish between a primary home, a second home, a short term rental, and a full time rental, and each label can push the policy toward homeowners or landlord forms. Before shopping for quotes, it helps to decide whether the property will mostly be a home, mostly an investment, or a mix of both.
Questions To Ask Before You Buy
Property owners can start by asking a few practical questions. Who lives in the property for most of the year. Is rent being collected on a regular basis. Does the owner keep many belongings in the home, or is it largely furnished by tenants. How often will the owner be on site to monitor maintenance and safety issues. Clear answers guide the insurer toward the right policy type.
Another key step is setting realistic coverage limits. For landlords, that usually means focusing on the cost to rebuild the structure and the amount of rental income that would need to be replaced if the property were out of commission for months. For owner occupants, that often means paying close attention to personal property limits and liability coverage high enough to protect both assets and future earnings.
Working With An Insurance Professional
Because the line between homeowners and landlord coverage can blur, especially with second homes or properties used for both personal vacations and short term rentals, a conversation with a knowledgeable agent or broker is important. A good advisor asks about how long guests stay, how often the property is vacant, and whether cleaning or maintenance crews enter regularly, then suggests either a homeowners policy with endorsements or a true landlord policy.
Owners should also ask pointed questions about exclusions, such as damage from tenants, certain types of water loss, or issues that arise when a property sits vacant for extended periods. The goal is a policy that matches the real world way the property is used, not just how it is described on paper.
Do Renters Need Insurance If The Landlord Is Covered
Many tenants assume that if the building is insured, their belongings and liability are automatically covered. That assumption can lead to harsh surprises after a fire, theft, or major leak. Landlord insurance typically protects the structure, not the tenant’s personal items or personal liability.
Industry professionals often explain that a landlord’s policy is written for the owner, not the occupant. It usually pays for structural repairs and may address situations where the owner is legally responsible for injuries or damage due to negligence. Tenants, on the other hand, need renters insurance to cover their own belongings and protect themselves if they accidentally cause harm to others or to the building.
This division of responsibility is also why more landlords are requiring proof of renters insurance in leases. When both sides carry coverage tailored to their roles, disputes after a loss are less likely, and each party knows which policy should respond to which type of claim.
Frequently Asked Questions About Homeowners And Landlord Insurance
The overlap between living space and investment property can make this topic confusing. These brief answers tackle some of the most common questions property owners ask when deciding between homeowners and landlord insurance.
Can I use my homeowners insurance if I rent out a room
Insurers often allow an owner to rent out a single room or a small part of the home under a standard homeowners policy, at least for occasional arrangements, but the details vary widely by company. If the property starts to operate more like a boarding house or full time rental, an insurer may require a different form of coverage.
What if I only rent my home on a short term basis
Short term rentals present a special challenge. Some insurers have endorsements that extend homeowners coverage to occasional short stays, while others treat it as a business activity that needs a different policy form. It is important to describe the rental pattern accurately so the insurer can recommend either specialized short term rental coverage or a landlord policy.
Does landlord insurance cover my tenant’s belongings
Generally, no. Landlord policies are designed to protect the structure, the owner’s fixtures or appliances, and the owner’s liability. Tenants almost always need their own renters insurance if they want protection for personal belongings and personal liability.
Can I switch from homeowners to landlord insurance mid policy
Yes, in many cases an insurer will rewrite a policy if a property’s use changes from owner occupied to tenant occupied. It is important to notify the insurer before signing a lease, so there is no gap in appropriate coverage.
Is landlord insurance tax deductible
Premiums for landlord policies are often treated as business expenses for tax purposes, since the coverage protects an income producing asset. Owners should confirm deductibility with a qualified tax professional who understands their full financial situation.
Final Thoughts For Owners And Landlords
The stakes around property insurance are rising. A recent study by a national association of insurance commissioners found that the average homeowners insurance premium increased by eleven point two percent in twenty twenty two compared with twenty twenty one, which shows how quickly coverage costs can climb from year to year based on an industry study.
For owners, that kind of upward pressure on premiums makes it even more important to buy the right type of policy. Paying for homeowners coverage that will not respond to tenant related losses is wasted money, no matter how low the rate looks. On the other hand, carrying landlord coverage when a property is used purely as a primary residence can mean paying extra for protections that are not needed.
The clearest path forward is an honest look at how each property is really used, followed by a candid conversation with an insurance professional. With the right mix of homeowners and landlord policies in place, owners can protect their homes, their investments, and their long term financial plans from the kinds of surprises that turn a simple claim into a serious setback.